It enables one to decide if a piece of software is ready to be released. Naturally the development organization cannot fix all of the problems arriving today or this week, so a tertiary measure of defect backlog becomes important. While this may seem like a negligible amount, the result is that major softwarereliant systems are being delivered and placed into operation with hundreds or even thousands of residual defects. Diagnosing medical device software defects using static. The denominator is the size of the software, usually expressed in thousand lines of code kloc or in the number of function points.
However, this measure does not consider the efficiency of the code. Software quality metrics overview semantic scholar. In the competitive commercial software market, software companies feel. The regular use of static analysis has proven to help software developers identify and eliminate many of these and other types of potential software defects. If you changed languages, it would affect the metric in any case, since the same program in another language might be less defectprone. The testers were rated based on could not reproduce defects. Requirements design source code user documents bad fixes secondary defects requirements and design defects often outnumber code defects. Estimating the number of residual defects yashwant k.
On the effectiveness of unit test automation at microsoft. Defects kloc assume that there is an average consequence to each defect. Pdf open source software oss development is considered an effective approach to ensuring acceptable. Those achieving levels below 1 defect per kloc per. In terms of time frames, various operational defin. How to reduce coding defects defect reduction techniques. Kloc what does it mean to software testing software. This is known as the defects per kloc lines of code. The software therefore had a lifetime defect count of 700 defects, and a defect density of 7 defects per 1,000 lines of code kloc. Reliability, availability, and defect rate availability. Predicting software assurance using quality and reliability measures. It measures the defects relative to the software size expressed as lines of code or function point, etc. It is possible to achieve zero defects but it is also costly. According to 22, for software applications developed by microsoft, defect density is about 1020 defects per kloc during inhouse testing and 0.
Sloc is typically used to predict the amount of effort that will be required to develop a program, as well as to estimate programming productivity or effort once the. Apr 06, 2020 research has suggested that highquality commercial software has roughly 0. This metric helps us in knowing the size and complexity of the software application. After release, the number would rather be 1 to 5 bugs per kloc in commercial software. I could also think of code checkers, static analysis and such things, but they wont find everything and produce a lot of noise. Applications are divided into functional areas or more technically kloc thousand lines of code. Academic research tells us that most commercial software contains 3 10 defects for every thousand lines of code kloc, and that 1% to 5% of these result in vulnerabilities.
In 2014, the average defect density for open source software was 0. The defect density metric, in contrast, is used in many commercial software systems. Apr 16, 2020 so, defect density is the compactness of defects in the application. Different studies have reported values between 10 and 50 defects per 1,000 lines of code kloc 21. Inadequate testing is one of the main reasons why software is typically delivered with approximately 2 to 7 defects per thousand lines of code kloc. A colleague emailed me a few days ago, and asked for a code base with a given size, what can we expect to see for numbers of defects per kloc given the actual industry average or given what the industry believes we should expect. There once was a project manager that pitted departments against each other. Automatic inspection defects found by static analysis tools along. Source lines of code sloc or loc is a software metric used to measure the size of a software program by counting the number of lines in the text of the programs source code.
Product quality metrics software quality metrics overview. Defects per kloc is a common measure used as a target or for evaluating code quality. Kloc is a measure of the size of a computer program. If defects per unit of functions is low, then the software should have better quality even though the defects per kloc value could be higherwhen the functions were implemented by fewer lines of code. Software quality metrics overview product quality metrics. He attributes this to a combination of codereading techniques and independent testing discussed further in another chapter of his book. In the competitive commercial software market, software companies feel compelled to release software the moment it is ready. More precisely, detection of 10% more defects in software design or coding phases. If youre testing prerelease software, this value could be much higher. The metric defects per kloc ignores the complexity and importance of all deliverables other.
The nasa space shuttle avionics software with an estimated defect density of 0. We specialize in ecommerce platforms like shopify, content management solutions cms like wordpress joomla expression engine, web applications, mobile design, responsive web design and graphic web design. Leading edge software development organizations typically achieve a defect density of about 2. Yes, and imho, one more key thing to remember is that though defects kloc is a good start, what it produces is an average. Based on extensive project assessments and benchmark studies, jones 2001 estimates the typical defect rate of software organizations at sei cmm level 1 to be 7. Pdf a study on defect density of open source software. Defect density is the number of defects detected in a software component. In other words he was using kloc as a surrogate measure for program complexity. It quality control is the process of testing software intensive systems to uncover defects and hence measuring actual quality.
Be sure that you understand that particular risk before using prerelease software. Mining metrics to predict component failures nachiappan nagappan microsoft research redmond, washington. Commercial software is any software or program that is designed and developed for licensing or sale to end users or that serves a commercial purpose. In the software development context test candidates can be specifications, design descriptions, code listings, executable software modules, units, subsystems or complete systems. Within the software development process, there are many metrics that are all related to each. Any measure is an arbitrary comparison of defects to code size.
Can defects per kloc be computed or at least estimated reliably and without bias. The defect rate metric, ideally, is indexed to the number of functions a software provides. A coverity study concludes that open source code using static analysis has on average a lower number of defects than commercial code, but they are on par when it comes to code of similar sizes. The business analysts were rated on their requirements defects. Why datacentric security is essential for legacy cobol. Freeware is free to use and does not require any payment from the user. I am unaware of a practical metric but the general problems of. Why patching for scada and ics security is a broken model. Vulnerability density versus defect density measured for some software systems. It calculates defect density by dividing the number of defects by the size of the component usually specified in lines of code. So, defect density is the compactness of defects in the application. In contrast, commercial software s defect density was 0. Each defect is unique, and sometimes, its the sum of a bunch of nonrelated defects that matter to the customers experience of the product. I am unaware of a practical metric but the general problems of using defects kloc are.
It quality control what is it quality control software. Pdf in the competitive commercial software market, companies feel compelled to release software the moment it is ready. Akiyama 1971published what we believe was the first attempt to use metrics for software quality prediction when he proposed a crude regressionbased model for module defect density number of defects per kloc in terms of the module size measured in kloc. Defect density is counted per thousand lines of code also known as kloc. Experience shows that cleanroom software typically enters system testing near zero defects and occasionally at zero defects. Sep 16, 2017 a software metric is a measure of software characteristics which are quantifiable or countable. While software creation by programming is a time and labor. We need some way of gauging whether or not our continue reading why defectskloc doesnt supply enough information about product quality. Commercial software can be proprietary software or free and opensource software. May 01, 2009 the regular use of static analysis has proven to help software developers identify and eliminate many of these and other types of potential software defects.
The developers were rated based on coding defects found by qa quality analysis. First, one measures the time between failures, the other measures the defects relative to the software size lines of code, function points, etc. Ok, so it is just a refined version of defect distribution. Shareware is also free to use, but typically limits the programs features or the amount of time the software can be used unless the user purchases the. In contrast, commercial softwares defect density was 0.
Gauging software readiness with defect tracking steve mcconnell. Research has suggested that highquality commercial software has roughly 0. Pdf an investigation of the relationships between lines of code. Mar 01, 2004 a colleague emailed me a few days ago, and asked for a code base with a given size, what can we expect to see for numbers of defects per kloc given the actual industry average or given what the industry believes we should expect. Yes, and imho, one more key thing to remember is that though defectskloc is a good start, what it produces is an average. Kloc has been used as a rough measure of programmer productivity, as in how many lines of code can you write a day. Introduction to kloc lines of code loc is one of the software metric that is used by most of the people for software measurement.
Commercial software was once considered to be proprietary software, but now a number of free and opensource software applications are licensed or sold to end users. This is true even though the c version had 65 total defects and the java version had only 50. Why defectskloc doesnt supply enough information about. Reliability, availability, and defect rate availability metrics. For missioncritical code, the count can be as low as. Computer software comes in three different flavors. Thus, the average number of defects in a section or per kloc of a software application is bug density. The two metrics are correlated but are different enough to merit close attention. Overall defect density during testing is only a gross indicator. Pdf gauging software readiness with defect tracking.
For system software typically it is observed requirements. The number of residual defects is among the most important measures of software reliability. It is also heavily biased against widely used software, because more users means more bugreports. Static analysis tools as early indicators of prerelease. Feb 28, 2007 lines of code loc is one of the software metric that is used by most of the people for software measurement. The size is determined by measuring the number of lines of source code a program has. This metric is used in many commercial software systems. Clean room software engineering for zero defect software.
Nasa was able to achieve zero defects for the space shuttle software, but at a cost of. Software metrics are important for many reasons, including measuring software performance, planning work items, measuring productivity, and many other uses. Ibms first commercial cleanroom product, was developed by a sixperson team. Many software defects are found in or after test when defect removal costs are the highest and the methods are the least effective.
1507 1648 477 816 988 43 258 418 240 848 1362 4 625 1443 531 593 396 757 703 1087 1452 548 1515 293 1393 1451 1012 20 878 726 1324 806 801 639 570 265